Thursday, January 7, 2016

Oil is extremely cheap

Arab Light oil fell to $27/bbl today, even as gold rose to $1108/oz. In terms of gold, oil has only rarely been this cheap.


The chart above shows the ratio of gold prices to oil prices. Today, one ounce of gold buys you almost 40 barrels of oil. That's only happened twice in the past 45 years (July '73 and July '86). In both instances, oil quickly rebounded.


The chart above shows that, in relation to other things (using the CPI as a proxy for the price of "other things"), oil is still above its all-time lows, but it is back to the levels that prevailed during the late 1980s and early 1990s, and it has fallen by a staggering 79% from its 2011 highs. This is the biggest percentage decline in oil prices to ever happen in the space of 14 months.


OPEC is refusing to cut back its oil production in order to preserve its market share, but U.S. producers have responded aggressively to collapsing prices. As the chart above shows, the active oil drilling rig count in the U.S. has plunged by two-thirds in the past 14 months. This implies a significant reduction in expected oil supplies, at the same time as consumers have responded by driving more (vehicle miles driven in the most recent 12 months are up 3.5% over year-ago levels, the first increase in 9 years). I think it's safe to say that it won't be long before oil prices rebound.

Oil prices are sending a powerful message to producers and consumers: produce less and consume more. Markets sometimes take awhile to fully respond to dramatic changes in prices, but they don't take forever.

China learns a costly lesson

The problem with China is not that the economy is collapsing, it is that the government is reluctant to let markets work. Bureaucrats and statists like to think that they know best, that markets are flawed and need limits and controls, but that's just hubris to the max. Markets aggregate the wisdom of millions when setting prices, and prices in turn send vital signals which help keep an economy running smoothly.

Government intervention in markets invariably results in unintended consequences, and China's "circuit breaker" on their stock market is only the latest example. When market participants are told that markets will shut down if stocks drop more than 7%, that only intensifies the desire to sell, as investors scramble to get out before the door shuts. The best way to keep capital in a market is to let capital know that it is free to leave whenever it wants. Turn off the circuit breakers and watch the market sort itself out!

Fortunately, China's securities regulator this morning announced the suspension of its circuit breaker program; bureaucrats learned a tough but important lesson. Although this is likely to provoke another stampede for the exits (after all, they might decide to reinstate the circuit breaker), in time the market—if left alone and given the proper assurances—will find the price that restores equilibrium. 

But it's not just the securities market that is having trouble, it's also the foreign exchange market, since the central bank is trying to fix the yuan's price with discreet adjustments to the yuan instead of allowing the currency to float freely. Eventually they will find the right price, but only at the cost of sowing uncertainty and squandering reserves. If the price of the yuan is too high, then the central bank will only fritter away its reserves trying to defend the price. That's what has been happening for the past 18 months, as China's forex reserves have dropped from $4 trillion to $3.33 trillion as of the end of December '15, and the central has been forced to cut the yuan's value from 6.05 to 6.59 per dollar. 

Markets are very powerful forces, and the Chinese economy and its markets are now so large that the government has essentially lost the ability to manage things according to bureaucrats' whims. This is good news for the long haul, but expect to see further dislocations along the way, because bureaucrats are loathe to give up their power.

Here's a quick look at how things stand.



The chart above shows the value of the yuan (blue) and the level of the central bank's foreign currency reserves (red). In a pegged currency regime such as China's, the central bank must purchase any net inflow of foreign currency. China enjoyed huge net inflows of capital for most of the past two decades because the economy was booming and foreign investors were eager to join the party. The central bank purchased some $4 trillion of foreign currency during this time, and that served to expand China's monetary base, essentially converting dollars into yuan to support a rapidly expanding economy. But the boom times are over, and capital flows began to reverse a year or so ago. The central bank was slow to react, however, and so it had to sell almost $600 billion of its reserves to defend what is now an "overvalued" yuan from the market's perspective. They don't want to do this forever, however, and so the decision to "devalue" the yuan back in August, and now to accelerate the decline of the yuan peg. Sooner or later they will find the right value of the currency which balances capital flows and restores confidence to the forex market, but it's an agonizing process. Better to just let the yuan float.


The chart above shows the inflation-adjusted value of the yuan vis a vis its trading partners, as of the end of November. Here we see that despite the August devaluation, the yuan was still very strong, having effectively appreciated by almost 100% since early 1994. Since November the yuan has dropped another 3% against the dollar, so I figure the yuan is now about 2-3% below its all-time high in real terms. That's not a collapse by any measure; the yuan is still one of the world's strongest currencies. It will probably decline further, especially if the government keeps trying to control the decline by selling reserves and doesn't allow a free float. But this should all be seen in the light of the economy's transition from rapid growth to more moderate growth. And in the context of powerful markets teaching hubristic bureaucrats a lesson.


The chart above shows the Shanghai Composite index. Note that even after the recent sharp decline, stocks are still more than 50% above their value as of 18 months ago. What was crazy was the huge runup in stocks from mid-2014 to mid-2015, during which time stocks rose some 160%.

China is going to eventually figure things out, and the economy is not going to collapse.

Wednesday, January 6, 2016

Reasons to avoid despair

There's no shortage of bad news these days.

China is in the midst a serious slowdown after years of barn-burner growth, the yuan is falling, and authorities are trying to keep the stock market from melting down. Commodity markets have been brutalized, especially oil. High-yield corporate bonds have tumbled. The S&P 500 barely eked out a positive return last year, and is off to a weak start this year. The ISM manufacturing index in December fell to its lowest level in over six years. The Middle East is deteriorating by the hour. Rogue states are gaining nuclear weapons capabilities, while terrorists are sowing fear in Europe and the U.S.. The U.S. body politic seems more isolationist than ever. The U.S. economy remains mired in its weakest recovery ever. A lack of confidence and burdensome tax rates have left business investment stagnant for the past four years, despite record-setting profits. Regulatory burdens are punishingly high. Neither of the two leading candidates for the U.S. presidency understands how the economy works, and both are advocating policies that could make things worse. And to top it all off, the Fed is raising rates despite tepid growth, a litany of troubling developments and very low inflation.

It's enough to make one despair. But the news is not all bad, and there is reason to think the economy will survive these problems as it has others before (e.g, the PIIGS crisis).



Pessimists argue that the Fed's easy money policies have inflated the prices of risk assets, but it's hard to square that claim with the facts in the first chart above, which shows that many risk assets have attractive yields relative to cash—which is one way of saying their prices are depressed, not inflated. The market price of the average high-yield corporate bond has fallen 17% in the past seven months, thanks mainly to the 40% decline in the price of high-yield energy sector bonds (which represent only 10% of the HY sector) since the middle of 2014, when oil prices began to collapse. Those price declines have pushed up the yield on the average high-yield bond to almost 9%. That's 710 bps more than the yield on 5-yr Treasuries with similar duration risk. That means the market is paying you over 7% a year to accept the risk of high-yield bond defaults. High-yield energy bonds are now yielding a staggering 16%. Emerging market debt carries yields of 7% or so, and the earnings yield on the S&P 500 is over 5%. If you're unwilling to take on risk, you must surrender a significant amount of yield, which is another way of saying that the market has priced in a lot of bad news.


The chart above shows the difference between the earnings yield on stocks and the yield on risk-free 10-yr Treasury bonds. It's unusual for the equity risk premium to be as high as it is today. Investors would not remain indifferent to such high yields on equity securities vis a vis their risk-free counterparts unless they expected earnings to decline in the future. Bad news is priced in.



There are still lots of worries about debt (e.g., the federal government owes $13.6 trillion, an amount equivalent to almost 75% of GDP), but when was the last time you heard someone point out that U.S. households' finances are in great shape? As the first chart above shows, households' financial burdens (monthly payments as a percent of disposable income) haven't been as low as they are now for over three decades. The household sector has managed a significant deleveraging during the current business cycle expansion, even as the government has leveraged up. In addition to deleveraging over the past seven years, household net worth has risen by $28 trillion to a current $84 trillion—a record-high level in nominal, real, and per capita terms—thanks to rising home prices, savings, and investment gains.


As the chart above shows, the U.S. economy has been creating jobs at the rate of just over 200K per month for the past 5 years. (The December ADP report released today suggests the payroll number to be released Friday is likely to be at least 200K.) We could and should be doing even better than that, but it's nothing to sneer at. The underlying problem is weak productivity growth, which has been averaging only 0.6% per year for the past 3 and 5 years, and is most likely the result of weak business investment. That pales in comparison to the 2-3% rates of productivity we saw in the mid-1980s and late 1990s. Still, even weak productivity coupled with 2% jobs growth gives you overall growth of 2.5% or so, and both these trends remain in place.



The PE ratio of the S&P 500 is just under 18 today, according to Bloomberg, and that is modestly above its 55-year average of 16.7. You might think that's a sign that the market is optimistic about the future, but it's not. As the first chart above shows, PE ratios tend to track the real yield on 5-yr TIPS, and—as the second chart suggests—that level of real yields is consistent with an expectation of real economic growth of only 1-2%. 

In other words, the economy has been growing around 2–2.5% per year since the recovery started, but the market worries that future growth will be more like 1-2%. 


Corporate profits have attained record-setting levels relative to GDP during the current expansion, and are currently far above historic norms. But the market worries that the economy will slow and  profits will be mean-reverting and that, in turn, implies zero or negative growth for profits for years to come. Again, bad news is priced in.



The first chart above reveals a significant downward trend in the prices of 5-yr TIPS and gold that has persisted for the past three years. (I use the inverse of the real yield on TIPS as a proxy for their price.) Why would investors be paying less and less for these two assets, both of which offer protection from financial storms? (TIPS offer inflation protection, while gold is a classic safe-haven asset which promises protection from a variety of risks, both financial and geopolitical.) The answer, I believe, is that investors have been slowly recovering the confidence they lost in the 2008 financial crisis and the PIIGS crisis in late 2011. I note that the prices of both of these assets peaked around the time of the Eurozone PIIGS crisis. Since then, as the second chart shows, consumer confidence has increased significantly, although it is still below previous highs. Confidence has returned, but markets are still cautious. Bad news is priced in.


The manufacturing sector has suffered, as reflected in weak growth in industrial production (down 1% in the past year) and a weak ISM manufacturing index. But manufacturing accounts for only 10% of total private payrolls: a mere 12.3 million workers out of total private payrolls of almost 121 million. Moreover, manufacturing has been a shrinking part of the economy for a very long time. Example: after the end of WWII, manufacturing payrolls represented fully 35% of total private payrolls. So the health of the much larger service sector is the thing to watch. As the chart above shows, the service sector is in decent shape, both here and in the Eurozone.

In my 2016 forecast, I call for a continuation of modest growth that is disappointingly slow. The reason I'm optimistic is that I'm seeing continued modest growth and very little chance of recession at a time when the market worries that conditions will worsen.

I fully acknowledge all the bad news out there, but the bad news has been around for a while and most of it is priced in. The economy has been sluggish precisely because of this bad news, which has sapped confidence and kept investment weak. If the news—and the policies—were to improve, we'd be seeing more confidence, more investment, and faster growth. If nothing improves, the economy is likely to continue plodding along at a 2–2.5% growth rate.